What is the difference between an appeal and an Administrative Review?
People use the words interchangeably. The Home Office does not. One is an internal re-check of the paperwork; the other is a hearing before an independent judge. You rarely get to choose between them — the type of application decides.
Administrative review
An internal Home Office process, governed by Appendix AR of the Immigration Rules. It is available for refusals of most points-based applications — Skilled Worker, Student, Graduate, the Global Business Mobility routes and others — and for some cancellations of permission at the border.
- Test: was there a caseworking error? That means the Rules or published policy were applied incorrectly, or evidence that was submitted was overlooked.
- Evidence: the review is on the evidence that was before the original decision-maker. New documents are only considered in narrow situations, such as where the refusal alleged deception.
- Deadline: 14 calendar days in the UK, 7 days if detained, 28 days for an entry clearance refusal.
- Fee: £80, refunded if the review succeeds or is invalid.
- Decision-maker: a different Home Office caseworker.
- Outcomes: the decision is overturned; maintained; or maintained with the reasons corrected (which may open a second review).
- Timescale: none published. Guidance provides for escalation only after 6 months, though many are decided sooner.
Appeal
A statutory right under section 82 of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 to have an independent judge in the First-tier Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) decide the case afresh. It applies to refusals of human rights claims (including partner, parent, private life and most family applications), protection claims, EU Settlement Scheme decisions and deprivation of citizenship.
- Test: would the refusal breach your human rights or the Refugee Convention? The judge decides on the facts as they are at the hearing.
- Evidence: new evidence is allowed and is usually essential — witness statements, updated documents, expert reports.
- Deadline: 14 days in the UK, 28 days out of country. Late appeals may be admitted if there is good reason.
- Fee: £82 for a decision on the papers, £144 for an oral hearing, with exemptions and fee remission available.
- Decision-maker: an immigration judge. Onward appeal on a point of law lies to the Upper Tribunal.
- Timescale: varies by hearing centre and case type; often many months.
Side by side
| Administrative review | Appeal | |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides | Home Office | Independent judge |
| New evidence | Generally no | Yes |
| Typical routes | Work, study, points-based | Family, private life, asylum, EUSS |
| Fee | £80 | £82 / £144 |
| Deadline (in UK) | 14 days | 14 days |
| Removal protection | Usually while pending, in-country | Yes, for in-country appeals |
What if neither applies?
Visitor visa refusals and most naturalisation refusals have neither remedy. The answer is a fresh, better-evidenced application — or, where the decision is unlawful, judicial review in the Upper Tribunal within 3 months, which requires a solicitor or a Level 3 adviser.
Where BBIS fits
As an IAA Level 2 practice we prepare and submit administrative reviews. We can assess appeal rights, advise on the merits of an appeal and assist with lodging an appeal within the applicable time limit. We do not currently conduct substantive Tribunal appeal work or advocacy. Where further representation is required, we will explain this and assist you in identifying an appropriately authorised representative. We will always tell you which remedy is available and which is worth pursuing before you pay a fee.
Tell us about your enquiry.
Send us your enquiry and we will explain how we can help. For tailored advice on your circumstances, book a one-hour immigration consultation (£150) by telephone, Zoom or WhatsApp.